OviflowOviflow
Blog
Get early access
Back to all posts
5 min read

Why the Lab Matters More Than the Doctor

Dan

If we had to pick one thing to research before choosing an IVF clinic, it would be this: the embryology lab.

Not the doctor. Not the reception. Not the website. The lab.

What the lab actually does

When you think of IVF, you probably think of the doctor. The doctor doing ultrasounds, setting the protocol, performing the retrieval. And yes, the doctor matters. But here’s what actually happens:

  1. The doctor retrieves the eggs - that takes maybe 15-20 minutes
  2. The lab does everything else - and “everything else” means everything

The lab is the one that:

  • Collects and selects the sperm
  • Selects viable oocytes
  • Performs fertilization (either conventional or ICSI)
  • Maintains embryos in a controlled environment for 5 days
  • Monitors embryo development
  • Evaluates embryo quality
  • Performs biopsy for genetic testing, if needed
  • Freezes and thaws embryos
  • Prepares the embryo for transfer

Each of these steps requires state-of-the-art equipment, strict protocols, and - most importantly - people with experience and attention to detail.

What we learned from our experience

We went through three clinics. The difference between them was most visible at the lab level.

At the first clinic, we had good initial results (fertilized embryos) that systematically collapsed by day five. We lost all embryos in two consecutive cycles. Nobody investigated whether the problem could also be at the lab level - the culture medium, handling technique, incubation conditions.

At the second clinic, with the same eggs from my wife and the same sperm from me (after the fragmentation treatment), the results were radically different. Embryos survived. They made it to day five. They could be genetically tested.

We can’t prove that the difference was exclusively the lab - the DNA fragmentation treatment mattered enormously. But we can’t ignore that at the second clinic, everything worked differently.

What you should research about a lab

Specific questions you can ask:

  • What incubation equipment do you use? Modern incubators with time-lapse (EmbryoScope, for example) allow continuous embryo monitoring without removing them from the controlled environment.
  • What’s your thaw survival rate? A good clinic should have rates above 95%.
  • How many embryologists work in the lab? A lab with a single embryologist doing everything alone is different from one with a dedicated team.
  • What sperm selection technique do you use? IMSI, PICSI, microfluidic chips - there are more advanced techniques than standard selection.
  • What are the clinic’s blastocyst rates? What percentage of fertilized embryos reach day five?

Red flags:

  • The clinic doesn’t want to discuss the lab
  • They can’t provide concrete statistics
  • The lab isn’t accredited or certified
  • They don’t invest in new equipment

The thaw-on-the-table story

A concrete example from our experience that perfectly illustrates the lab’s importance:

At the second fertilization at the first clinic, we had a single frozen embryo. We traveled about 200 kilometers - roughly two to three hours of driving - for the transfer. My wife was already on the operating table, prepared.

Only then did we learn that the embryo didn’t survive the thaw.

At serious clinics, the embryo is thawed several hours before transfer. Its progress is observed. Viability is confirmed. And then the patient is prepared.

At our clinic, everything was done at the same time. We traveled 200 kilometers for nothing. My wife prepared for transfer for nothing. And we went home empty-handed.

A professional lab would have never let that happen.

The doctor is important, but…

We don’t want to minimize the doctor’s role. A good doctor sets the right protocol, adjusts doses based on ovarian response, decides optimal timing for trigger and retrieval, and - very importantly - investigates the causes when things don’t work.

But the doctor is, in a sense, the front of house. They manage the big picture. The lab is the one that executes the actual procedure. And if the lab isn’t at the highest level, no protocol in the world will compensate.

Our conclusion

Think of it this way: you choose a restaurant based on the chef, not the waiter. In IVF, the doctor is the waiter - important, necessary, but not the one making the food. The lab is the kitchen.

Research the kitchen.

References

This is the fifth in a series of articles about our IVF journey. We’re sharing what we learned across 6 cycles, three clinics, and five years - not as medical advice, but as the honest account we wish we’d had when we started.

Dan